Homepage / Atlanta News
E-Mail News Alerts
Get breaking news and daily headlines.
Browse all e-mail newsletters
Related To Story
NBC

Court Rejects 'Deal Or No Deal' Suit

POSTED: 10:38 am EDT April 21, 2008
UPDATED: 11:05 am EDT April 21, 2008

Georgia's top court unanimously ruled Monday against a Georgia couple who wanted NBC to repay them and other residents for the cost of sending 99-cent text messages to win a prize on the game show "Deal or No Deal."

Michael and Michele Hardin sued NBC, hoping to recover the text message charges they ran up playing the show's "Lucky Case Game," which challenged viewers to guess which of six on-screen gold briefcases was the lucky case.

The couple's lawyer, Jerry Buchanan, called the game an illegal gambling operation and said state law allowed them to retrieve money from a winner because "gambling contracts are void."

NBC attorneys, however, said it was a promotional tool and not a lottery. They also contended that the network was not the "winner" of the game, so should not be targeted by a legal challenge.

The Georgia Supreme Court ruled that the text messages cannot be classified as a bet or a wager, and so residents were unable to prove there was a "gambling contract" needed first to prove a claim for the money.

The ruling, written by Justice Hugh Thompson, says that as a result, the law "offers no avenue of recovery to plaintiffs."

Calls to Buchanan and Joe Loveland, an attorney representing NBC, were not returned.

The NBC show, hosted by Howie Mandel, calls for a contestant to predict the amount of cash contained in any of 26 sealed briefcases. The top prize for guessing correctly is $1 million.

It is unclear what the ruling will mean for the "Lucky Case Game," which was also the target of at least one court challenge in California. NBC has halted the game since the lawsuit, and it is described on the show's Web site as "taking a short break."

Links We Like
Sponsored Content
You can pick your friends, but not your family -- or your neighbors. Here's what you need to know about how to deal with yours. More

Are you often tired or rushed in the morning? Give your morning habits a makeover, and start the day feeling positive and energetic instead. More

Do you want the look of a quality paint job without the hassle of having to redo it over and over? Spray on siding could be the answer. More

Find out exactly what Medicare covers with our easy-to-use Medicare coverage tool. More

Sponsored Links